Pit Bulls are a collective of dog breeds that have come a long way since their early days. Once a fighter, they’re some of the most loving dog breeds today. But if you’re considering bringing home a Pit Bull, you may be wondering just how intelligent they are.
The Pit Bull, namely the Staffordshire Bull Terrier and American Staffordshire Terrier, are average to above average intelligent dogs. For obedience & working intelligence, they’re the 94th and 48th smartest dog breeds, respectively. While this may not impress owners, Pit Bulls tend to have high adaptive IQ, which is the ability to learn for themselves and through past experiences.
Despite their relatively low rankings on the dog intelligence list, Pit Bulls are much smarter than you think. Despite popular belief, dog intelligence isn’t all about obedience. Let’s examine what really makes these dogs so intelligent and why they rank low according to the “experts.”
RECOMMENDED: 100 Most Intelligent Dog Breeds
Table of Contents
- What’s Considered a “Pit Bull?”
- How We Measure a Pit Bull’s Intelligence
- The Stigma of the “Dumb” Pit Bull
- 2 Reasons Why Pit Bulls Are Actually Smart
- Is Your Pit Bull Smart?
- Is the Pit Bull For Me?
What’s Considered a “Pit Bull?”
Before we continue, we must first clarify what the “pit bull breed” is. There’s a lot of confusion in the canine world. But the reality is that the Pit Bull is not a single dog breed. Rather, they’re a collection of four dog breeds and direct relatives to those pedigree breeds.
That being said, there are four types of Pit Bulls: the American Pit Bull Terrier, American Staffordshire Terrier, Staffordshire Bull Terrier and the American Bulldog.
And despite the confusion, these four breeds are the only dog breeds in the pit bull category. In fact, many dogs in animal shelters have been classified as Pit Bulls just because “they look like one.”
So in this article, when we refer to the intelligence of Pit Bulls, we will be talking about just those four specific Pit Bull dog breeds. Two of which, are dogs actually recognized by the American Kennel Club.
How We Measure a Pit Bull’s Intelligence
Measuring the intelligence of a dog is, without question, a difficult task. After all, it’s not like we can have them take a written IQ test. The truth is, there is no way to quantify intelligence in dogs. And although obedience & working IQ may be the closest, it still have its flaws.
This dimension of canine intelligence (obedience and working) was developed by Stanley Coren, a renowned pHD and canine psychologist. In essence, it measures how quickly a dog can learn a command – in addition to how well a dog retains their training.
So with the help of 199 obedience trial judges from North America, Coren was able to infamously develop the dog intelligence ranking list that we’re able to critique today.
Coren’s Dog Intelligence Criteria
Based on Stanley Coren’s trial criteria, each obedience judge tested as many dog breeds as possible. And with that data, he formed his final rankings.
His criteria was based on the following:
- The number of repetitions it took for a dog to learn a new command. Dogs that needed fewer repetitions ranked higher on the list.
- The success rate at which a dog will obey a known command on the first try. Those that had a higher success rate were considered smarter and more obedient.
Unfortunately, not all dog breeds took part in Coren’s trials – it’s why not all four Pit Bull breeds tested for dog intelligence in the trials. Only those recognized by the American or Canadian Kennel Club participated. In addition, dog breeds needed at least 100 responses to qualify.
Because only the American Staffordshire Terrier and Staffordshire Bull Terrier are recognized breeds, they were the only Pitbull-type breeds that participated in the trials. Thus, we only have data on those two dogs for obedience and working intelligence.
How the Pit Bulls Performed
Overall, the two representatives of the Pit Bull dogs did fairly well. While the Staffordshire Bull Terrier ranked 94th out of 138 breeds, the American Staffordshire came in at 48th place.
These results placed the Staffordshire Bull Terrier in the “average intelligent” class. On the other hand, American Staffordshire Terriers scored in the “above average intelligent” class. That’s great – but what does this actually mean for these dogs?
This meant that the American Staffordshire Terrier is able to learn a new command with just 15 to 25 repetitions. Furthermore, these Pit dogs will also obey a known command (on the first attempt) with a 70% or better success rate. They’re obedient and quick learners!
Performing slightly worse, the Staffordshire Bull Terrier is capable of learning a new command with only 25 to 50 repetitions. In addition, they have a 50% or better success rate with obeying commands on the first try. Not too bad at all!
Overall, these Pit Bulls didn’t do too bad. There’s nothing wrong with being average, and in the American’s case, they did better than average.
Pit Bulls vs The Smartest Dogs
Now that we know how smart the two recognized Pit Bulls are, how do they compare to the brightest? The most intelligent dog breeds in the world are in a class of their own. In fact, they’re the top 10 smartest breeds!
These dogs are capable of learning a new command with fewer than 5 repetitions. In addition, they’re likely to obey a known command on the first try with a 95% or higher success rate!
This means they’re at least 3 times faster at learning new commands than the Pit Bulls. In fact, you’d probably be able to teach these dogs a basic command in just a few minutes! Plus, they’re much more “obedient” too.
The Stigma of the “Dumb” Pit Bull
With all these Pitbull owners claiming their dogs to be highly intelligent, in addition to the decent obedience & work IQ, why do some people believe that Pit Bulls are low intelligent dogs?
It all comes down to the temperament of these dogs. Not all dog breeds will “work” for the sake of working, such as the Border Collie. Similarly, not all dogs will do your bidding “just because.”
According to Rover, Pit Bulls have a lot of energy and determination, which can come off as stubbornness and willfulness. Owners will tell you that these dogs can certainly go on their “stubborn streaks” from time to time.
I feel horrible but I’m at my wits end trying to find a way to get Buddha to behave himself. I know he knows his commands and can be a good dog (he shows me that on his “good” days). He’s just being super stubborn.– Buddhasmommy (Pit Bull owner)
Because Coren’s dog intelligence trials were based on obedience & working intelligence, stubbornness could be the detrimental quality that led them to rank lower than they should.
Though we think how fast a dog learns is correlated with intelligence, Coren’s trial is essentially an obedience test. As such, the more stubborn dogs don’t usually do well with this type of test.
But just because your Pit Bull doesn’t obey you doesn’t mean your dog doesn’t understand what you’re asking. As Buddhasmommy described, her pit knows his command but doesn’t always follow. That is, the stubbornness of the Pit Bull.
2 Reasons Why Pit Bulls Are Actually Smart
Obedience and working intelligence is a great starting point when measuring a dog’s IQ. However, it doesn’t tell the full story. Not even close.
And according to Stanley Coren, there are two other dimensions of dog intelligence: Instinctive and adaptive intelligence. These two areas are where Pit Bulls really shine in intelligence.
Versatility is Dog Intelligence
Instinctive intelligence refers to the ability or skill that the dog was bred for. In the past, all dog breeds, including the Pit Bulls, were bred for a specific purpose in society. Most of the time, their roles benefited humans one way or another. For example, herding dogs were bred for, well, herding.
The natural ability to push livestock (cattle, sheep) toward directions and formations require a special type of IQ, that is, instinctive intelligence. Knowing where to position themselves to guide flocks is intelligence. Keep in mind, they’re able to do this with little to no human training.
And although these Pit Bull dogs were originally bred for bull-baiting, ratting and other “dark” jobs, they were later reinvented and bred to be multi-purpose dogs.
Not only were they fantastic companions, but also capable guardians, vigilant watchdogs and tireless workers. They were some of the most versatile breeds back in the day (and probably still are!).
All these jobs and roles that Pit Bulls once had (and still serve) doesn’t mean they’re just versatile, but that they also have high instinctive intelligence. Think of them as the jack-of-all-trades in the canine kingdom.
The Pit Bull’s Adaptive Intelligence
Stanley Coren believes that the final dimension of dog intelligence is adaptive intelligence. It is perhaps the most important, as it refers to the ability of the dog to learn for itself. Dogs with low adaptive intelligence rely a lot on guidance from their owners.
But what exactly is adaptive intelligence? You may ask yourself: is my Pit Bull able to learn from past mistakes and previous experiences? Can the dog communicate with humans in a feasible way? These are all questions regarding adaptive intelligence in dogs.
And while instinctive intelligence is roughly the same for all Pit Bulls, adaptive intelligence can vary from dog to dog. Some dogs will be more adaptable than others.
Fortunately, most Pit Bulls are known to show high adaptive intelligence. For instance, one Pit owner tells us:
My Tanner and Zoe are too smart. I went inside to get my car keys and Tanner was laying on the floor eating his cookies. In the short amount of time I was outside, he figured out how to open the cabinet to get to his cookies.– Zoetanner (Pit Bull owners)
Tanner the Pit was able to learn how to open cabinets, likely by observing his owners (learning from his previous experiences). In addition, he knew the best time was when his owners were gone. All this points to a clear sign of adaptive intelligence in Tanner.
Another Pit Bull owner tells us a similar story, saying:
I have a smart pit bull. I’ve been treating Quinton for a hotspot. And every time he sees my supplies, he’ll walk over and lay down on his own. It must not feel good when I clean it so it’s saying a lot.– Teasha (Reddit User)
Quinton knows what’s about to happen, so he happily complies. The cues in his example are the supplies. This Pit Bull learned that certain supplies result in a following consequence or action. Again, another spot-on sign of high adaptive intelligence in these dogs.
Though these are just two examples, there are plenty more on the web (we just couldn’t list them all). And, if you ask any Pit Bull owner, they’ll likely tell you similar stories.
What the Pit Bull lacks in obedience training (and not all of them), they more than make up for it with their natural ability to learn. Performing tricks and obeying commands is great, but adaptability is what makes the Pit Bull truly an intelligent dog breed.
Is Your Pit Bull Smart?
Like with humans, the true intelligence of your Pit Bull can vary from dog to dog. However, we believe the best way to gauge a breed’s intelligence is by asking the owners.
With that said, we surveyed the popular Pitbull Subreddit and other dog forums to ask real Pit Bull owners whether they believed their dog was intelligent. Here’s what these owners had to say to the question.
Real Owner Answers:
1. Throwawayhelp123456 says Yes: “We have had my pit bull for a week now, after she was in a shelter for 2 years. She is incredibly smart, and very much a confident and alpha dog.”
2. Turnipkid7 says Yes: “Chomper, our pit, is super smart. He’s a little stubborn at times but you know he’s intelligent from how he interacts with humans.”
3. Zoe says No: “Pit bulls are smart? You haven’t met my red nose pit bull, Tank (aka Big Dummy). We don’t call him ”dummy” for nothing!”
4. Cavscoutwife says Yes: “The Pit bulls intelligence level and ease of training is a huge bonus to many types of families. Above all else, those of us that love the breed, adore their huge smiling faces!”
5. Houstonsfinest says Yes: “Don’t underestimate the intelligence of the pitbull. We’ve raised many in our lives and we’re always so pleased with their capability and obedience.”
6. Toni H says Yes: “Pit bulls are extremely smart dogs and learn faster than lightning. Very good dogs to be around if you love them openly and often.”
7. Jon_jordan says No: “I hate to admit it, but they’re not the smartest dog around. They are, however, very loyal and very protective.”
8. Shermanf says Yes: “My red nose pit bull is sooo smart. They’re some of the smartest dogs i’ve ever seen…give them a chance!”
9. Williamssherwin says No: “My pit is a little goofy and silly most of the times, but in no world is he smart. But does it really matter? He’s the most loving dog I’ve ever owned.”
10. Surfserps says Yes: “After owning a German Shepherd, Doberman and American Pit Terrier, the Pit is the smartest. Not the most obedient, but feels like he just understood situations better.”
Is the Pit Bull For Me?
All four Pit Bull breeds are great dogs for everyone. And while obedience can be a little difficult, it’s not always the case. Yes, Pit Bulls are stubborn dogs. However, they’re both people-oriented and loyal dogs. As such, Pit Bulls will do their best to comply with training.
Don’t listen to the myth about Pits being “dangerous dogs.” They may have the most dog bite incidents, but it’s likely due to negligence and poor training from bad owners. After all, they were the “premiere” fighting dogs so it’s inevitable they’d sometimes attract a certain type of owner.
Overall, Pits are great dogs with high intelligence. Don’t let these “experts” tell you whether your dog is smart or not. And the truth is, all dogs are smart enough to give you what you need.
Bring home a Pit Bull today and you won’t regret it! They’re some of the most affectionate and kind dog breeds, despite what media portrays them to be.
Do you own a Pit Bull? Let us know how intelligent your dog is! Leave a comment in the section below!
Posts you may like: